Deliberation time. The prosecution and defense each have rested. The fate of the defendant is now in the hands of the jury. The suspense of a courtroom drama heightens. Guilty? Not guilty? That is the question.
The legal movie genre is filled with courtroom drama, action, thrillers and humor. And while the movies don’t always reflect what happens in real life, they can nonetheless provide a glimpse into the legal profession. If you’ve seen more hours of Law & Order than I’ve spent in law school (and who hasn’t?) I’d like to offer you a list of movies that might serve as an alternative to the TV drama. Some of them are purely entertaining. A good number of them will teach you something about the profession I’m about to embark on. So, in no particular order (except for the movies in spots 1 & 2) I offer you my list of must-see legal movies:
27. The Ox-Bow Incident - A Western lynching drama made under the shadows of WWII. A good contrast to the type of justice we strive for.
26. Intruder in the Dust - Nowadays almost every movie involving racism, murder, lawyers, and infuriated crowd ends up in the court in an endless trial. This one does not; everything happens in a small south town or in the country around.
25. A Dry White Season - Donald Sutherland plays a South African school teacher, and Marlon Brando a human rights attorney hired to investigate the death of a school employee’s son.
24. Call Northside 777 - Based on a true story of a Chicago reporter who proved that a man who has been in prison for murder was wrongly convicted.
23. Young Mr. Lincoln - Henry Fonda stars in this true-story portrayal of Abraham Lincoln in a courtroom drama.
22. Adam’s Rib - B&W portrayal of women in the law.
21. The Sweet Hereafter - Shows the complexity of the lawyer character, not the glamorized image of the lawyer’s power.
20. North Country - a fictionalized account of the first successful class-action sexual harassment lawsuit in the U.S.
19. A Time to Kill - Even though the defendant committed premeditated murder, it’s hard to condemn him.
18. My Cousin Vinny - Funny and fun to watch because of the rules of evidence and the cross-examination techniques that it demonstrates.
17. The Firm - Glorification of the entry-level attorney who outsmarts his employers, the mob and the FBI.
16. A Few Good Men - A dramatic, but inaccurate representation of military justice, full of hot-shot courtroom antics.
15. Class Action - A stark reminder of the devious and sometimes abusive discovery tactics sometimes used in big cases.
14. Presumed Innocent - Full of surprising plot twists and rules of evidence.
13. ...And Justice for All - Al Pacino shakes the legal system to its foundations, the integrity of the judges and their ability to deal out true justice.
12. Murder in the First - The true story of a 1941 trial that shows a now-popular “criminal as victim” defense.
11. The Thin Blue Line - The flaws in the justice system may leave district attorneys more worried about prosecuting someone than about prosecuting the right person.
10. Erin Brockovich - A movie about the kind of heroism, perseverance, and skill required to take on high-paid corporate attorneys.
9. The Paper Chase - Terrific portrayals that law students can show to friends and family who don’t believe you when you say law school is really, really tough.
8. Inherit the Wind - Outstanding in its portrayal of one of the most famous and controversial trials in American history. Good representations of the voir dire process and illustrates what can happen when a fair trial is impossible.
7. The Verdict - Paul Newman’s character is in a lot of trouble. Not only does he have an alcohol problem, but in the course of the film he also makes all kinds of mistakes that could get him disbarred.
6. The Accused - One of the few movies to tackle “criminal solicitation” which is inciting another person to commit a crime.
5. Michael Clayton - This film shows the legal ethics dilemma some lawyers face in their responsibility to their clients and society.
4. Kramer vs. Kramer - A Best Picture winner, this movie illustrates the now largely defunct “tender years” rule, which once almost guaranteed mothers custody of young children.
3. Anatomy of a Murder - Dramatic, hard-edged trial movie replete with dedicated attorneys, a wise and reasonable judge, and a surprise ending.
2. Twelve Angry Men - An in-depth exploration of the concept of reasonable doubt and realistic insights about how the jury system works.
1. To Kill a Mockingbird - A moving story about right and wrong and an attorney who lives up to the highest ideals of his profession.